Best Shaving Soaps: Top 6 Soaps Reviews
Getting a high-quality old-school shave requires investing in good quality products & other that the razor itself, there’s no another product where this is truer that when it comes to choosing the best shaving soaps. Now it is time to help you sort over a large number of products to get the best shaving soap that fit your needs.
A traditional wet shave always requires spending the money on a good quality shaving soap, otherwise, you may shortly find that the additional time wet shaving takes may not be worth it. Absolutely, wet shaving is more than just the shaving soaps, as the entire process is the reason why it can provide more comfortable and closer shave. So investing in a good quality shaving soap means the difference between a great and a good shave.
In the past, soaps were mainly the domain of men who used straight razors, or at the least. DE safety razors (you can check What’s the Best Safety Razor?) . However, considering the large difference in quality between a cheap canned cream and a good shaving soap, we would recommend them to any special man who is searching for a higher quality shave.
Best Shaving Soaps Comparison Table
|Taylor Shaving Soap||8.5 ounces||$$||4.3|
|RazoRock XXX Shaving Soap||4.8 ounces||$||4.4|
|Truefitt & Hill Shaving Soap||5.6 ounces||$$$||4.8|
|Mitchell Shaving Soap||4.8 ounces||$||4.7|
|Tabac Shaving Soap||19.2 ounces||$||4.6|
|D.R. Shaving Soap||9.1 ounces||$$||4.6|
Choosing a Shaving Soap: Semi-Hard, Croap or Triple-Milled?
If you have never used soaps before, there are a few things you should know before buying one. For wet shaving beginners, you should be aware of the fact that most shaving soaps require a preparation time before shaving, as the shaving soap will need to be soaked in water for a few seconds to soften it up. So, if you are always in a hurry, you’d go with a shaving cream. On the other hand, there are now also a number of decent creams-soaps (croaps) on the market that can offer a similar quality without presoaking it. Nonetheless, if you have got the time, we recommend choosing a high-quality hard soap.
If you are deciding to use a traditional shaving soap, you’ll need to invest in a good shaving brush, as shaving soaps cannot be lathered with your hands. On the other hand, if you don’t want to go the full 9 yards with the brush, you can find a somewhat croap or softer soap that doesn’t require a brush.
Most of the best shaving soaps are triple-milled, which makes the puck harder and results usually in a product that lasts a bit longer than croaps and the softer soaps. However, triple-milled soaps are the most expensive shaving cream you can get, with some products costing fifty dollars for a single puck. Nonetheless, you can expect to get a few weeks of use out of 1 puck, meaning they are much cheaper in the long run.
The last thing to consider when searching for the best shaving soaps is whether or not you will be using a shaving bowl or mug. Although they are unessential, even in wet shave, you can find that some brands of shaving soaps require bowl to make the best lather. I sure do live in my bowl. Still, when looking for your shaving soap, you’ll rapidly see that some pucks come in their own container, tin or bowl, while with other products you will only get the puck.
In truth, the difference between the 2 is the price, as the products without bowl are usually a bit cheaper than those that come with the bowl. Nonetheless, you can always kill 2 birds with 1 stone, as you can buy refill puck and reuse the same bowl over and over again. On the other hand, If you plan to go with bowl-less puck first time, you’ll need to invest in a container to soak the soap in (or use tea mug or any container from your kitchen).
Choosing the Best Shaving Soaps: Glycerin vs. Oil vs. Tallow
The last thing to consider when looking for the best shaving soap is the ingredients themselves. For old-school shave, tallow based soaps are the only way to go. Nonetheless, nowadays there is a quantity of perfect products that are made using oils (such as argan, palm, coconut or olive oil), some of them work easily as well as the tallow-based products.
Not only that, but some guys find the idea of using an animal-fat based soap (tallow is rendered animal fat) slightly off-putting, which helps to clarify the popularity of oil-based shaving soaps.
Finally, there are many new soaps that are now being made using glycerin. While glycerin may be a great choice for regular or lotion soap, most men find the majority of glycerin-based shaving soaps to be inferior to those made of oil or tallow. That being said, this isn’t always the case, as there are some oil-based shaving soaps that are downright terrible, while there are at a very least a few decent glycerin-based soaps on the markets today.
The Best Shaving Soaps on the Markets
If you’re a shaving enthusiast or have read our review of the best shaving cream, then you are probably already familiar with Taylor. Generally speaking, English shaving tools have a reputation for being the best in the world, and amongst the best English soaps, Taylor of Old Bond Street is the best.
The company actually produces a numerous of different scents of soaps including Sandalwood, which has a classic scent that fades away soon after using. It also comes in some other good exotic scents including Grapefruit and Avocado! For around $25 for a reusable wooden bowl and a puck, we feel you’d be a little hard-pressed to find a better soap for the price. Nonetheless, there are numerous of men who report this soap dries out their skin because of the fact that it contains palm oil in addition to glycerin. While the glycerin gives more lubricant, this soap still may not be the best picked for those who often suffer from dry skin.
While I prefer English shaving soaps, I recently planned to expand my horizons & one product that stood above the rest in my search was RazoRock XXX Shaving Soap. I am a big fan of their alum bloc and natural deodorant and their soap didn’t disappoint. This Italian made product is really soft and more of (cream-soap) than a true shaving soap—making it great for those who cannot be bothered to take additional time to soak a soap or find that hard soap dry out their skin. Although I stay away from (croaps), I should say I was gently surprised with the performance of this particular product.
Not only is it incredibly very easy to create a good lather, but it’s also 1 of the most lubricating soaps I have come across in a long time due to the combination of lanolin and coconut oil. The slickness of this soap really is something to behold. In addition to, it also does a great job at resulting in an incredibly smooth, painless shave, protecting the face. The smell is also good—having woody, floral and citrus notes—making it both reminiscent of an old-school shave. Anyway, this is really one of the best (creams-soaps) on the markets. In fact, the only complaint I have that it uses artificial fragrances instead of essential oils. On another hand, this is a 5-star cream soap.
Like Taylor, Truefitt and Hill are another soap of the most well-respected English brands, and the only one named as the official shaving goods of the British Royal Family. In terms of smell, we discover that most of their scents (including Trafalgar and the popular 1805) to smell a little bit more like something your grandfather used, but this isn’t a bad thing if you’re searching for something ultra-traditional.
We discovered that the Truefill and Hill soaps didn’t dry our skin as much as those from Taylor (despite the fact that both contain oil in addition to glycerin), on the hand, they cost about twice as much with bowl and puck typically selling for $44-60 or around &24 for only the soap puck. For old-school shaving enthusiasts, it doesn’t get better than Truefitt and Hill, although there are numerous of similar quality goods for a lower price.
If you’re searching for an all-natural soap that uses organic ingredients, we recommend Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shaving Soap. This one contains primarily lanolin and made from sheep (hence the name) instead of synthetic or vegetable oil, which is precisely why we like it, as there is no doubt that animal fat provides the best results than vegetable oil. Not only will this soap not dry out the skin, but it also creates one of the most lubricating and richest lathers we’ve come across.
At around $15 for a puck (or around $35 for bowl and puck), this is as good as you can get for its price and is hands down our number 1 picked for those searching for a true wet shave. After using it, you’ll immediately see why Mitchell’s has improved such a cult following amongst shavers in the know.
English shaving products are very good that Tabac is 1 of only 2 non-English products to make our list. Still, there’s nothing not to like about this soap. It does not smell like tobacco but instead has a masculine, floral and citrusy scent. Still, some guys find it to be a bit off-putting, but we think it’s a great change from the others.
Like Mitchell, this is another traditional tallow-based soap that works like a magic. Nonetheless, many guys find it a little bit harder to get a proper lather at first, but you must instantly get the hang of it. The puck of soap itself sells for around $20, or you could purchase it with a hard plastic container for another $10. However, in truth, we would recommend buying a separate container if you want to go with this product, as the plastic container this product comes with seems quite cheap.
Another soap with a misleading name, just like Tabac shaving soap, D.R. smells nothing like tobacco but instead has an ultra-manly scent. While it’s not our favorite scent in the whole world, there are a large number of guys who swear by it. Still, if you love the soap but not the scent, you will be glad to know that D.R. (another soap of the most liked English brands) also makes soaps in Windsor, Arlington, and Lavender.
We discover that the D.R. soaps produce perfect rich lather, and with less effort than many other products. However, there are also those who considered it inferior, so your mileage may vary. We still feel it provides a perfect value for the price (around $30 for beautiful wooden bowl & puck)
If you found this post helpful please be very kind as to share it on social media. We would appreciate it as we have worked very hard on this article for you. I think some of your family or friends will find it helpful as well. Don’t hesitate too much just pick the best shaving soap from this list and try it